I consider myself to be lucky to have ended up with the family that I did. I love them very much and I am glad that if I had to be adopted, that I was adopted by them. But I am not grateful for being adopted. I'm grateful to my parents for putting a roof over my head after I graduated from college so that I could put that money towards my loans (and at the end of the year towards a down-payment on a condo). They didn't have to do that for me. My adoption had nothing to do with it. They would have done that for me if I was their biological daughter. And I would have been grateful all the same. See the difference? It's a nuance that not everyone picks up on, but it's there. But nothing changes the fact that I will never be grateful for being born and ending up with the family I was placed with. Those things just happened. That's just how it goes.
Regardless of adoption, I don't think that children should have to be grateful to their parents for bringing them into this world. Here's my reasoning. Most people have children because they want them. There are people out there who do not want children (my first parents fell into that category when I was born). Some of those children are adopted, some are raised poorly, and others are raised well. But for the majority of people, their parents wanted to have children. I know that out of all my cousins (who are all biologically related), only one of them (that I know of) wasn't planned on and that cousin isn't loved any differently than anybody else. A few may have been one too many than originally planned on (there are two sets of twins), but my aunts and uncles were all trying to have kids, with the exception of one, possibly two. So what that means is that they weren't brought into the world because it was what was best for them. After all, until they were born they didn't really exist anyway (you can replace born with whatever you feel appropriate; I just don't feel like getting into those semantics here). So should they feel grateful that their parents wanted children? I don't think that's a fair thing to say.
I also think that for any child who was intentionally added to a family, either through birth or adoption, the stakes are higher. The parents made a decision to add to their family. They knew that would mean putting a roof over their child's head. They knew it would mean feeding and clothing them. They knew it would mean teaching them right from wrong and everything in between. They knew it would be a huge responsibility. So I don't think they should get to whine and complain about it later. I don't think that they should get to tell their children "After all I've done for you..." It's just not fair.
I'm not talking about being disrespectful to your parents. And I'm not talking about not being thankful for what you have if you have a good situation. I'm all for that. But that's up to the person. I can feel thankful but I would never tell someone else that they have to feel that way too. It's just not how it all works. So I don't think that any parent should be able to tell their children that they should be grateful for how they were raised. Especially their adult children. I just don't think it's right.
I don't think it's fair for my friend's mother's cousin to tell me that I should be grateful for my adoptive parents. Who they do not know. Because that's just how adoption is. I automatically should be grateful. But here's the thing. I'm not automatically grateful. If you want me to be grateful for you, you need to work at it. You have to do something above and beyond. My parents did not adopt me for my sake. They adopted because they wanted a child. That's the simple truth. They are fantastic people, but they are not saviors, nor have they ever expected to be treated that way. I was the solution to their fertility issues. And to their credit, they've never asked me to be grateful for my adoption. Not once. I've been told to be grateful for other things (like the annoying itchy sweaters I was given as a gift as a small child but didn't like), but never for my own adoption. So I do not appreciate other people telling me to be grateful. It's unwanted and I'd appreciate it if you'd stop.
And before you assume that this post is because I don't have good adoptive parents, I'm coming to see that I'm very lucky with the parents that I have. My parents freely gave me things, without strings. They moved to a suburban town so that my sister and I could get a good education. They made sacrifices for us. Later, my mother confessed that looking back, she would do things differently because the town we moved to was a tough town to grow up in at times. The point is, my parents made a lot of choices for me and my sister and sacrificed. They drove further to work and worked longer hours so that my sister and I could get the best start and have the best chance to make something of ourselves. They wanted to open as many doors as they could for us. And they never once have told me that I "owe" them for any of it. I'm not expected to pay them back. I'm not expected to do anything. I've never been spoken down to because I made a decision my parents didn't like. And I know people (adoptive and biologically related to the parents who raised them) where this is not the case. And I'm thankful that I have a good set of parents, but please never tell me to be grateful for them without knowing anything.
I guess my point is, telling another person to be grateful is probably not the best way to make friends. And it's probably not going to actually make them feel grateful.